1823 1C Private Restrike Silver

PCGS MS63

The 1823 1C Private Restrike in Silver represents a fascinating chapter in numismatic history, primarily due to its rarity, intriguing background, and the mystique surrounding its creation. Unlike official mint issues, this piece is recognized as a private restrike—the product of post-mint activities meant to satisfy collector demand during a time when such practices were not uncommon. The tale of this coin is steeped in historical curiosity and speculative intrigue, capturing the admiration of collectors worldwide.

Rarity and Mintage

The 1823 1C Private Restrike Silver is exceedingly rare, a key element of its allure and high market value. The exact mintage figures remain elusive, partly due to their unofficial nature; however, it is known that restrikes were produced in very limited quantities, likely fewer than a couple hundred pieces. The clandestine and unregulated minting process meant that accurate record-keeping was not a priority, contributing to the mysterious charm of these coins.

Historical Context

In the early 19th century, large cent enthusiasts faced periods where official mint productions were limited or nonexistent. Private entities like the enigmatic "Mr. Adams" produced these restrikes from original dies or die copies to cater to collectors eager to fill the gaps in their sequences or possess something uniquely different. Historically, such products have been a testament to the ingenuity and entrepreneurial spirit of private minters, straddling the line between historical authenticity and collectible novelty.

PCGS Coin Facts

According to PCGS Coin Facts, the coin carries the designation of PCGS #402638. While official mint issues have widely recognized PCGS numbers, private restrikes like this one shed light on the broader historical narrative of coin collecting. The coin's existence in PCGS's catalog underscores its legitimacy and recognition within the numismatic community, notwithstanding its unofficial origins.

Market Value and Auction Sales

The market for the 1823 1C Private Restrike Silver is driven by its rarity and the stories it carries. For instance, recent transactions at prestigious auction houses underscore its desirability among collectors. In a noteworthy sale, one of these pieces fetched a price approaching $18,800, reflecting both its scarcity and sustained demand. This value is not merely a reflection of its silver content but also of its historical and collectible significance. Detailed auction records reveal fluctuating interest and intense bidding, with these coins often commanding high premiums—the result of fierce competition among collectors aiming to own a piece of numismatic lore. These sales demonstrate the coin's standing as a desirable addition to any 19th-century collection, offering a window into a time when numismatic curiosities emerged from unofficial yet captivating sources.

Numismatic Perspective

From a numismatist's viewpoint, the 1823 1C Private Restrike in Silver is an artifact that encapsulates the dynamic nature of early American coin collecting. It tells a story of a past where collector desire could spur ingenuity and innovation outside the realm of official channels. For those immersed in the study and collection of early American coinage, this piece is not only a treasure but also a conversation starter about the numismatic practices of the era. In conclusion, the 1823 1C Private Restrike Silver coin stands as a testament to the rich and varied history of American coinage. Despite its unofficial origins, it remains a cherished piece among collectors, encapsulating the spirit of numismatics: preserving and cherishing the past, with all its intricacies and stories, for future generations.


Back to blog